A Brief History of the Evangelical Church’s Relationship with Conservative Black Americans and Why This Legacy Demands Today’s Spiritual Leaders Use Effective Communication for Racial Reconciliation
The Conscious Conservative Pro-life Initiative: Equipping Evangelical Leadership with Tools for Effective Pro-life Outreach and Supporting Black Families with More Empowering Pro-life Choices
The Conscious Conservative Pro-life Initiative, founded in 2025 by Coach Felecia Killings, is a branch of The Felecia Killings Foundation’s national Black Outreach work.
Our mission is to build an alliance between conservative Black American voters and Evangelical leadership in pursuit of pure racial reconciliation and expansion of the conservative voting bloc on a national level.
In addition, we desire to see more empowering pro-life choices available to Black communities nationwide.
Our work of ministry is 100% financed by our Beloved Givers Community, our CCM Leadership Members, and Evangelical Leadership Clients like you.
A Brief History of the Evangelical Church’s Relationship with Conservative Black Americans and Why This Legacy Demands Today’s Spiritual Leaders Use Effective Communication for Racial Reconciliation
The relationship between the Evangelical Church and conservative Black Americans is a complex tapestry woven with threads of shared faith, painful betrayal, and enduring hope. From the era of slavery to the Civil Rights Movement and beyond, Black Christians have navigated a spiritual landscape often marked by both profound connection and bitter disappointment. Understanding this history is crucial for comprehending the present challenges and opportunities for racial reconciliation within the Evangelical community, placing a unique demand on spiritual leaders to foster healing through effective communication.
The Evangelical Roots of Shared Faith
The First Great Awakening of the 18th century played a pivotal role in introducing Christianity to enslaved Africans. Evangelical preachers, emphasizing personal conversion and emotional religious experience, resonated deeply with those yearning for spiritual solace amidst the dehumanizing realities of slavery. Figures like George Whitefield, although a plantation owner and slaveholder, preached to large crowds that included both whites and blacks, offering a quasi-message of equality before God that challenged the racial hierarchy of the time. This early evangelicalism, though often compromised and shrouded with conflicting racism by the prevailing social norms, laid the groundwork for a shared faith experience.
Black converts embraced Christianity, reinterpreting it through the lens of their own experiences and cultural traditions. They found in the stories of liberation, suffering, and ultimate triumph a reflection of their own struggles. This led to the development of distinct Black spiritual expressions, including the emergence of spirituals—songs of lament, resistance, and hope that drew upon both biblical narratives and African musical traditions. These spirituals became a powerful form of cultural and spiritual resistance, offering a means of expressing their faith and asserting their humanity in the face of oppression.
The Divisive Legacy of Slavery
The issue of slavery proved to be a deeply divisive force within the Evangelical Church. While some Evangelicals actively opposed slavery, many others either defended it on biblical grounds or remained silent, prioritizing social and political expediency over moral conviction. This complicity with slavery created a deep rift between Black and white Christians, undermining the promise of spiritual equality.
Following the Civil War and Reconstruction, the rise of Jim Crow laws further entrenched racial segregation and discrimination. Black Christians faced exclusion from white-dominated churches and were subjected to systemic racism in all aspects of life. In response, Black denominations such as the African Methodist Episcopal (AME) Church, the National Baptist Convention, and the Church of God in Christ (COGIC) flourished, providing spaces for Black worship, leadership, and community empowerment. These denominations became centers of social and political activism, advocating for civil rights and economic justice.
Become a Premium Subscriber to Coach Felecia Killings Omnimedia and Join Our Beloved Givers Community for $25/Month
This Sunday’s reward includes:
The Conscious Conservative Leadership Guide: Homeschool to the Rescue: Teaching Parent Leaders How to Successfully Enter the Homeschool Wonderland (a $25 value)
The Civil Rights Era and the Promise of Integration
The Civil Rights Movement of the mid-20th century brought renewed hope for racial reconciliation within the Evangelical Church. Black Christian leaders like Martin Luther King Jr. drew upon their faith to advocate for nonviolent resistance to segregation and discrimination. King’s powerful rhetoric, rooted in biblical principles of love, justice, and equality, resonated deeply with both Black and white Americans.
However, the response from white Evangelicals to the Civil Rights Movement was mixed. While some actively supported the movement, many others remained silent or even opposed it, clinging to traditional racial hierarchies and resisting calls for integration. This division further alienated Black Christians and reinforced the perception that the Evangelical Church was not truly committed to racial equality. Even within denominations that professed support for integration, deeply ingrained patterns of segregation and discrimination often persisted.
The Rise of the Religious Right and its Impact
The emergence of the Religious Right in the late 20th century further complicated the relationship between the Evangelical Church and Black Americans. While the Religious Right successfully mobilized Evangelical voters around issues such as abortion and traditional family values, its focus on these issues often overshadowed concerns about racial justice. Furthermore, the Religious Right’s alignment with conservative political causes alienated many Black Christians, who felt that their concerns about poverty, inequality, and systemic racism were being ignored.
Moreover, the rhetoric employed by some leaders within the Religious Right often perpetuated racial stereotypes and divisions. This contributed to a growing sense of mistrust and resentment among Black Christians, who felt that their voices were not being heard or valued within the broader Evangelical community.
The Demand for Effective Communication
Given this complex and often painful history, spiritual leaders today face a unique demand to foster racial reconciliation through effective communication. This requires a willingness to acknowledge the sins of the past, to listen to the experiences of Black Christians, and to engage in honest and open dialogue about race and racism.
Firstly, leaders must cultivate humility. Acknowledging the historical complicity of the Evangelical Church in perpetuating racial injustice is a crucial first step. This involves actively learning about the experiences of Black Christians, recognizing the ways in which racism has shaped their lives, and developing current solutions so the next generation walks in total healing and power.
Secondly, leaders must prioritize listening. Creating spaces for Black Christians to share their stories and perspectives is essential. This requires active listening, empathy, and a willingness to hear uncomfortable truths. It also means valuing Black voices and perspectives within the leadership structures of the church.
Thirdly, leaders must model courageous conversations. Facilitating honest and open dialogue about race and racism is critical for breaking down barriers and building bridges. This requires creating safe spaces where people can share their thoughts and feelings without fear of judgment or reprisal. It also means challenging racist attitudes and behaviors whenever they arise.
Fourthly, leaders must promote cultural competency. Understanding the cultural differences and nuances within the Black community is essential for effective communication. This involves learning about Black history, culture, and traditions, and recognizing the diversity of experiences within the Black community, including recognizing the conservatism in fellow Believers.
Fifthly, leaders must advocate for justice. Racial reconciliation is not simply about individual relationships; it also requires systemic change. This means advocating for policies and practices that promote racial equality and address systemic racism in all its forms. It also means using the church’s resources to support Black communities and organizations working for social justice on the basis of Conscious Conservatism.
Theological Imperatives
Beyond practical communication strategies, a solid theological foundation is essential for driving racial reconciliation. Evangelical leaders must ground their efforts in core biblical principles. The concept of Imago Dei, the image of God in every person, demands that all individuals be treated with dignity and respect, regardless of race. The Gospel’s call for justice (Micah 6:8) requires actively working to dismantle systems of oppression and inequality. The imperative to love one’s neighbor as oneself (Mark 12:31) compels Christians to cross racial divides and build relationships based on mutual understanding and compassion.
Furthermore, the doctrine of reconciliation in Christ (2 Corinthians 5:18-20) provides a powerful framework for addressing racial divisions. Just as God reconciled humanity to himself through Christ, Christians are called to be agents of reconciliation in a broken world. This involves acknowledging the brokenness of racial relationships, seeking forgiveness for current sins, and working to create a more just and equitable society.
Ultimately, effective communication for racial reconciliation is not merely a matter of technique; it is a matter of discipleship. It requires a commitment to following Jesus’s example of love, justice, and compassion, and a willingness to challenge the status quo in order to create a more inclusive and equitable church and society.
The journey toward racial reconciliation within the Evangelical Church is a long and arduous one. There will be setbacks and challenges along the way. However, by embracing a spirit of humility, prioritizing listening, modeling courageous conversations, promoting cultural competency, and advocating for justice, spiritual leaders can help to heal the wounds of the past and build a more just and equitable future. The task is monumental, but so is the potential for healing and restoration, for embodying the true spirit of Christian unity, and for reflecting the Kingdom of God on earth.
And this is the message we preach through The Conscious Conservative Pro-Life Initiative. We aim to empower more Evangelical leaders who have a pure heart and desire to see revival and reformation in their communities.
If you are a ministry leader or community leader, and you need help with building an effective communications system in your organization that boosts membership AND builds a solid relationship with diverse communities (like conservative Black Americans), contact us today and schedule a FREE 25-minute consultation.
Our premium leadership training and communications services are designed to work with Evangelical churches and conservative political organizations through our in-person and online training.
We also have a premium DIY bundle package for smaller organizations, which contains my signature communications system formula. This bundle -- complete with dozens of e-books, workbooks, and video presentations -- has helped rising leaders (and their organizations) move from obscurity to national prominence in the social, political, and economic spheres using the principles of Conscious Conservatism.
To be considered for this experience, let us get to know you and your organization better when you complete our FREE application and schedule a FREE 25-minute consultation with us to discuss your vision and needs.
Until next time, Beloved, be blessed.
And as always, let’s grow together!
Coach Felecia Killings