Current Trends in American Churches and How Evangelical Leadership Can Make Strides to Grow Their Memberships and Connect with Diverse Communities
The Conscious Conservative Pro-life Initiative: Equipping Evangelical Leadership with Tools for Effective Pro-life Outreach and Supporting Black Families with More Empowering Pro-life Choices
The Conscious Conservative Pro-life Initiative, founded in 2025 by Coach Felecia Killings, is a branch of The Felecia Killings Foundation’s national Black Outreach work.
Our mission is to build an alliance between conservative Black American voters and Evangelical leadership in pursuit of pure racial reconciliation and expansion of the conservative voting bloc on a national level.
In addition, we desire to see more empowering pro-life choices available to Black communities nationwide.
Our work of ministry is 100% financed by our Beloved Givers Community, our CCM Leadership Members, and Evangelical Leadership Clients like you.
Current Trends in American Churches and How Evangelical Leadership Can Make Strides to Grow Their Memberships and Connect with Diverse Communities
The American religious landscape is in constant flux, influenced by societal shifts, technological advancements, and evolving spiritual needs. Today, it is crucial for spiritual leaders to understand the emerging trends and adapt their strategies to effectively engage their congregations and communities.
In this empowering post, let’s explore several key trends impacting American churches. In this analysis, I will also offer practical adjustments that leaders can implement to bolster membership and foster deeper connections with their communities.
The Decline in Church Attendance and Community Impact
According to current research:
The decline in church attendance can be attributed to multiple factors, ranging from shifts in religious beliefs to lifestyle changes and broader societal trends.
Generational shifts: Pew Research (2019) found that while 55% of baby boomers (born 1946-1964) reported attending church at least once a week in the 1980s, only 38% of Millennials (born 1981-1996) and 20% of Gen Z (born 1997-2012) do so today. Barna (2022) suggests that Millennials and Gen Z often feel disconnected from traditional religious practices. Many view organized religion as outdated, overly dogmatic or out of touch with contemporary issues.
The rise of secularism: The trend toward less religious belief and practice has significantly affected this decline. According to Gallup (2021), fewer Americans identify as Christian, and the percentage of those who are religiously unaffiliated has increased dramatically.
Changing family dynamics: Pew Research (2020) points out that many families no longer prioritize religious practice similarly. Divorce rates, single-parent households and the increase in dual-income families have all contributed to the rethinking of traditional family values, including religious attendance. For many families today, Sunday mornings are often occupied with sports, social events or simply taking a break from a busy week rather than attending church services.
Of all these trends, the most polarizing factor causing people to abandon the Church today is politics. I know this conservative political space well. And it is not a coincidence that God the Holy Spirit brought my voice and leadership platform right here to equip Evangelical leadership and the people with the message of the pure Kingdom of God.
The Rise of the “Nones” and Declining Religious Affiliation
One of the most significant trends is the increasing number of Americans identifying as religiously unaffiliated, often referred to as the "Nones." This group includes atheists, agnostics, and those who simply do not identify with any particular religion. Pew Research Center studies consistently show this group growing, particularly among younger generations. Several factors contribute to this trend, including:
Disillusionment with Organized Religion: Some individuals have become disillusioned with perceived hypocrisy, scandals, or outdated doctrines within religious institutions.
Increased Secularization: Modern society offers alternative frameworks for meaning and purpose, reducing the perceived need for traditional religious institutions.
Individualism and Autonomy: A growing emphasis on individual autonomy and self-discovery leads some to reject prescribed religious beliefs in favor of personal spiritual exploration.
Political Polarization: The increasing alignment of some religious groups with specific political ideologies alienates those with differing views.
Adjustment: To address this trend, Evangelical leadership must prioritize authenticity, transparency, and relevance. This involves:
Creating Safe Spaces for Doubt and Questions: Foster an environment where individuals feel comfortable expressing doubts and asking challenging questions without judgment.
Embracing Dialogue and Critical Thinking: Encourage critical engagement with scripture and tradition, rather than blind adherence to dogma.
Focusing on Social Justice and Compassion: Demonstrate a commitment to addressing social injustices and serving the needs of the community.
Promoting Interfaith Dialogue: Engage in respectful dialogue with people of different faiths and worldviews.
The Digital Church and Online Engagement
The digital revolution has profoundly impacted how people connect, learn, and engage with information. Churches must embrace digital platforms to reach new audiences and enhance the experience of existing members. This includes:
Livestreaming Services and Events: Provide online access to services and events for those who cannot attend in person.
Developing Engaging Online Content: Create informative and inspiring content, such as videos, podcasts, and blog posts to share on social media and church websites.
Utilizing Social Media for Community Building: Foster online communities through social media groups and forums where members can connect, share, and support each other.
Offering Online Bible Studies and Courses: Provide convenient and accessible learning opportunities for individuals seeking to deepen their understanding of faith.
Adjustment: Churches should invest in technology and training to effectively utilize digital tools. This involves:
Creating a User-Friendly Website and Mobile App: Ensure that the church's online presence is accessible, informative, and easy to navigate.
Training Staff and Volunteers in Digital Communication: Equip individuals with the skills and knowledge to create engaging online content and manage social media platforms.
Investing in High-Quality Audio and Video Equipment: Enhance the online viewing experience by providing clear audio and video.
Prioritizing Online Security and Privacy: Protect the privacy of members by implementing appropriate security measures.
Become a Premium Subscriber to Coach Felecia Killings Omnimedia and Join Our Beloved Givers Community for $25/Month
This Sunday’s reward includes:
The Conscious Conservative Leadership Guide: Teaching Leaders How to Bring Their Stories to the Top and Empower Their Readers Through Their Books (a $25 value)
50% OFF coupon to attend The Conscious Conservative Leadership Convention (online and in Atlanta, GA) this October 3-5, 2025 (a $750 value)
50% OFF coupon for The Write Conservative Book Publishing Package: A DIY Digital Bundle (Including Video Presentations, E-Books, and Workbooks) That Teaches Rising Leaders How to Write, Publish, Market, and Sell Their Self-Publishing Books (a $750 value)
The Growing Importance of Community Outreach and Social Impact
In an increasingly polarized and individualistic society, people are seeking meaningful connections and opportunities to make a positive impact on the world. Evangelical leaders can play a vital role in addressing social needs and fostering a sense of community. This includes:
Partnering with Local Organizations: Collaborate with nonprofits, schools, and community groups to address local challenges.
Offering Volunteer Opportunities: Provide opportunities for members to serve the community through various outreach programs.
Adjustment: Churches should prioritize community outreach and social impact by:
Conducting Community Needs Assessments: Identify the most pressing needs in the local community and develop programs to address them.
Empowering Members to Lead Outreach Initiatives: Provide training and resources to enable members to lead and participate in outreach programs.
Celebrating Community Partnerships and Achievements: Recognize and celebrate the contributions of volunteers and community partners.
The Shift Towards Experiential Spirituality
Many individuals are seeking more experiential and embodied forms of spirituality that engage their senses and emotions. This includes:
Contemplative Practices: Incorporate practices such as meditation, mindfulness, and prayer walks into worship and spiritual formation.
Creative Arts: Utilize music, art, dance, and drama to express faith and connect with God.
Nature-Based Spirituality: Offer opportunities to connect with nature through retreats, hikes, and outdoor worship services.
Service and Pilgrimage: Engage in service projects and pilgrimages to deepen spiritual awareness and connect with others.
Adjustment: Evangelical leaders can cater to this trend by:
Creating Multi-Sensory Worship Experiences: Incorporate visual, auditory, and tactile elements into worship services.
Offering Workshops and Retreats on Contemplative Practices: Provide opportunities for members to learn and practice contemplative techniques.
Supporting Creative Arts Ministries: Encourage and support artists within the congregation to express their faith through various art forms.
Organizing Outdoor Activities and Retreats: Offer opportunities to connect with nature and experience spirituality in a natural setting.
The Importance of Authentic Leadership and Relational Connection
In an era of skepticism and distrust, people are seeking authentic leaders who are transparent, compassionate, and relatable. Evangelical leaders must prioritize relational connection and create a sense of belonging for their members. This includes:
Building Strong Relationships: Leaders should prioritize building relationships with members and creating opportunities for connection within the congregation.
Practicing Active Listening and Empathy: Leaders should listen attentively to the concerns and needs of members and respond with empathy and understanding.
Sharing Personal Stories and Vulnerabilities: Leaders should be willing to share their own stories and vulnerabilities to create a sense of connection and trust.
Empowering Members to Lead and Serve: Leaders should empower members to use their gifts and talents to lead and serve within the church and community.
Adjustment: Evangelical leaders should focus on developing authentic leadership and fostering relational connection by:
Providing Leadership Training and Mentoring: Equip leaders with the skills and knowledge to lead effectively and build strong relationships.
Creating Small Groups and Fellowship Opportunities: Offer opportunities for members to connect with each other in smaller, more intimate settings.
Prioritizing Pastoral Care and Counseling: Provide pastoral care and counseling services to support members through difficult times.
Celebrating Diversity and Inclusion: Create a welcoming and inclusive environment where everyone feels valued and respected.
In Conclusion …
As American churches navigate the changing landscape, it is essential for spiritual leaders to be aware of the emerging trends and adapt their strategies accordingly.
And this is the message we preach through The Conscious Conservative Pro-Life Initiative. We aim to empower more Evangelical leaders who have a pure heart and desire to see revival and reformation in their communities.
If you are a ministry leader or community leader, and you need help with building an effective communications system in your organization that boosts membership AND builds a solid relationship with your community, contact us today and schedule a FREE 25-minute consultation.
Our premium leadership training and communications services are designed to work with Evangelical churches and conservative political organizations through our in-person and online training.
We also have a premium DIY bundle package for smaller organizations, which contains my signature communications system formula. This bundle -- complete with dozens of e-books, workbooks, and video presentations -- has helped rising leaders (and their organizations) move from obscurity to national prominence in the social, political, and economic spheres using the principles of Conscious Conservatism.
To be considered for this experience, let us get to know you and your organization better when you complete our FREE application and schedule a FREE 25-minute consultation with us to discuss your vision and needs.
Until next time, Beloved, be blessed.
And as always, let’s grow together!
Coach Felecia Killings